What's the best automatic gearbox?

I started driving in the 1970s and have always had negative thoughts about automatic transmission - namely slow and thirsty. Clearly the world has moved on and there are some very good auto/semi auto transmission systems out there, but which are the best, and more importantly, which should be avoided? To give some context, I'm looking at buying a medium sized estate, probably about five years old. Any advice appreciated.

Asked on 12 February 2019 by John Ward

Answered by Andrew Brady
I much prefer an automatic gearbox for day-to-day driving, but they can still be problematic. Certain DSG gearboxes used in Volkswagen Group cars can be troublesome, as can Ford's Powershift transmission. CVT gearboxes - popular with Japanese car manufacturers - are generally very reliable, but aren't the most pleasant to use. The dual-clutch transmissions used in Kia and Hyundai models seem pretty robust as does the torque converter used by Mazda.
Similar questions
Based on my experiences with the Volkswagen DSG I want a proper old-school torque converter automatic. What do you suggest?
I am looking for a medium-sized automatic petrol car for £15,000?
We would like to replace our Skoda Yeti with a second-hand automatic car that is easy to get into. Having never had an automatic and heard horror stories about some automatic gearboxes what recommendations...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer