Warranty extras - Nice little earners?

When I recently bought a new Auris hybrid, I was offered various "extras" in insurance and protection and wonder which, if any, you would recommend taking out. These are:

1) 3 years guaranteed paintwork protection and upholstery protection (this seemed the best deal as we have 11 grandchildren) but is it really worthwhile?
2) alloy wheel repair insurance.
3) Tyre insurance.
4) Retail price protection (sometimes I believe called GAP).

As they each cost around £350-£400 I do seriously need some unbiased advice and wonder if they're all just a scam to rake off more money from the unwitting customers.

Asked on 21 January 2010 by JM, via email

Answered by Honest John
The only ways a salesman can make money on a new car these days is by selling extras, most of which are mostly commission (for him). Paint protection is necessary because all cars built in the EC have to be painted with watercolours, the surface of which is very weak and needs protection. But only buy paint protection if it is unconditionally guaranteed and you should not have to pay more than £200 for it anyway. That still gives the salesman about £125 of commission on the deal. I’d never heard of tyre insurance before.

Never heard of wheel rim insurance either. GAP insurance is another commission earner. This is usually about a third of the price bought from an independent insurance broker, from who I guess you could also buy tyre and wheel insurance at lower rates. If sales managers adopted the principle of lifetime service this would not be necessary.

The idea is you have a single contact at the dealership – the salesperson from whom you originally bought the car. And he or she looks after you for everything: servicing, accident repairs, tyres, batteries, insurance, extended warranty, earning a smaller commission on each of these, then a bigger commission when you come back for your next car.
Similar questions
My Dad has been having horrendous trouble with his Volvo XC60. He purchased it from new in June 2011. Since then it has spent many, many weeks back at Volvo. The computer system fails in part - taking...
My car is due out of warranty next month. I have just been advised by Green Flag (starting problem) that the fan belt and tensioners are worn, and should be changed. The car has done 35,000 miles. Is...
Our vicar is looking to change her eight year old FIAT Punto. She looked at a pre-owned Toyota Auris Hybrid, wanting to go green, but it was an expensive option. She needs an economical five-door with...
Related models
Decent combination of ride and handling that might suit some people better than a harder sprung Golf or a Civic. A few inches taller than a Golf of Focus so easier to get in and out.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer