How can insurance companies justify premium increases for no reason?

Why has my car insurance increased by about 40 per cent to £390.68 when I have had no change of circumstances? Why can I buy the same insurance with the same underwriter on a price comparison site for £275? I believe it is a despicable marketing ploy more suited to the Krays than a respected financial institution.

Asked on 19 October 2012 by SC, Bolton

Answered by Honest John
Most car ‘insurers’ are actually really brokers and have been taken over by Private Equity Funds who exploit a captive market for a compulsory product. In the past, insurers used car insurance as a loss leader to get customers for other types of insurance. Not any more.

The best is currently LV, which remains a mutual. That said, most insurance premiums are open to negotiation. If they cannot rip you off tor £400, they would rather take £200 off you than nothing at all.
Tags: insurance
Similar questions
Is it okay for someone else to drive my car while I'm serving a disqualification, or is the insurance void as it's only insured for me to drive? Can someone with third party cover on their insurance policy...
What do I have to do to put my Cat S car back on the road?
If you drive another car but it has got no insurance, does yous insurance cover you to drive it?
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer