Would you recommend a 3-door car for our daughter's first car?

We are looking to buy a 3-year-old used car for our 17-year-old daughter who has just started driving lessons. Although we've narrowed our choice between a Toyota Yaris, for reliability, or a Fiat 500, reliable and funky, my wife prefers a 5-door car because she thinks it is safer. Any thoughts please?

Asked on 11 October 2013 by JC, Kew

Answered by Honest John

There's no logic in that except that it's easier for rear passengers to escape from a 5-door car after a crash. Fiat 500s are exceptionally reliable and the Lounge models have useful features like integrated 'Blue&Me' Bluetooth that can be upgraded online to suit new generations of phones.

Tags: doors safety reliability young drivers specification

Similar questions

Can you recommend a reliable, safe 3-door car to replace our daughter's Volkswagen Polo?

My daughter lives in the south of England and does a fair bit of motorway driving. She currently has a Volkswagen Polo that is eight years old and is starting to cost her money. We would like to help replace...

Which small car for my 17-year-old daughter?

My 17-year-old daughter has just started driving and I think it would be more cost effective to buy her a small car rather than try to insure her on the family car. Safety and reliability are definitely...

Which small reliable cars offer a good safety rating?

What other used models the same size as a Yaris, with a good safety rating are worth looking at? Or are they much of a muchness at this size car? We certainly don't want larger than Yaris size.

Related models