Admin fees - are they justified?

Some dealers are adding an extra fee to the purchase price of their vehicles.
At least one of the car supermarkets add an extra £96 as a pre-delivery fee - apparently a "preparation" cost. When I asked for a more specific cost breakdown, I was told that the car would be valeted before collection. Which, of course, they do anyway when they put the car up for sale.
A Land Rover main dealer, (Sturgess), add £72 for "admin". This was for the "paperwork for the sale" including the HPI check. (Even to a private individual, Experian only charge a few pounds for this.) Hunters, another Land Rover franchise, have no such fee and I subsequently bought my car from them.
A cynic may say that these insidious charges, although unjustified, are a nice little earner - what's your view?

Asked on 14 June 2015 by Steve Mass

Answered by Honest John
I hate this on new cars and think it's disgraceful. BMW does it on BMW and MINI models. Toyota does it. The only price of any relevance and the only price that should ever be quoter is the final, on the road price. If they add anything to the quoted list price, just walk out. For used cars, the fees are much less: about 15% of what BMW charges on a new car, and they have been around a long time, so I don't resent them as badly. Just add them to whatever price the dealer is advertising the car for then negotiate the final price you have to pay down from that.
Similar questions
If a car bought from a major franchised dealership develops a serious problem within six months would it make more sense to insist the original dealer fix it for free rather than make a warranty claim...
I have just picked up a six-month-old Jaguar XF with less than 4000 miles on the clock, from a Jaguar garage. On driving home I noticed a mark on the windscreen, which turned out to a repaired chip. The...
I have been sold a car that has been involved in an accident but there was no mention of the accident when purchasing. What can I do?
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer