Buying a Renault Megane Sport Tourer - which model is best?

I'm looking to buy a new Renault Megane sport tourer GT - I need the extra room and like the sportier look of this estate, I'll be going for a manual but I can't decide which engine variant to go for though - 3 choices:

1. Petrol 1.2 TCE 115 (119 Co2 £30 tax)
2. Diesel 1.5 DCI 110 (93 Co2 £0 tax)
3. Diesel 1.6 DCI 130 (104 Co2 £20 tax) +£300 for this engine

If you have any knowledge of expected reliability, actual economy, performance, noise etc or generally any advice you can give it would be much appreciated.

Asked on 3 February 2016 by draked

Answered by Honest John
This is actually new/old model Megane because a new Megane is already being built but won't come to the UK until summer. The 1.6DCI 130 is the best diesel engine. The 1.2TCe is much smoother. Tested here: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/renault/renault-me.../
Similar questions
I do around 18,000 miles a year, of which 14,000 or so are business, for which I get 45p a mile. I need a new car; should I get a petrol or diesel for this sort of mileage? I'm concerned about the government's...
I am currently getting PCP quotes for a new XC90. I was torn between the D5 and the T5, but the quotes have pretty much made my mind up. The list price for a D5 Momentum is £550 more than the new T5, yet...
Our 2004 Jeep Grand Cherokee is tired and we fancy a Mercedes-Benz ML-Class 3.0. We're wary of diesels because we only do trips of about 10 miles. Should we be wary? If so, what's a good petrol alternative?
Related models
Plenty of interior space. Good comfort levels and easy to drive. Revised model from 2014 looks good. Well refined.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer