I bought a Honda Legend with mismatched tyres - will it pass an MOT?

I have bought a Honda Legend from a Honda dealer. On closer inspection after delivery (yes, I was too trusting of Honda), I have found that three of the four tyres match the manufacturer's specification of 235/55/R17 100W. However, the front offside tyre is an odd one in several respects. It is a directional tyre with a totally different tread to the others, a Goodyear 235/501ZR 17 96Y. Is such a mix legal, and what is the position in relation to the MOT? I did also visit an MOT centre and they looked at me rather blankly.

Asked on 6 September 2010 by Nick WGC

Answered by Honest John
Pay for the MoT station to inspect the tyre and provide a written report on its legality. if they say it is illegal take the evidence back to the Honda dealer and if he won't replace the offending tyre take the matter to the small claims court.
Similar questions
On March 29 my car passed its MoT with advisories on the exhaust and rear bushes. Today my tyre blew while driving and I had to call the AA. The recovery driver was disgusted at state of my tyre and wondered...
I bought a used car online. The seller said he was a trader and the car was advertised as a part-exchange, just MoT'd with a one year warranty. I booked to view it (80 miles away) over the weekend at his...
My dad purchased me a 2009 MINI about two months ago, in which time I've done 2000 miles. When the car went for it's MoT, it passed with a minor refusal for headlight bulb but was advised an engine management...
Related models
Plush and crammed full of advanced technology. Five-star crash test rating. Capable of driving itself. Surprisingly quick, and very comfortable.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer