What calculations do insurers use to work out premiums?

I recently replaced my group 40 SUV, valued at £9000 with an annual premium of £640, with a much newer group 15 car of similar value with a premium of £400. I expected the insurance to have at least halved given the difference in insurance groupings. Is there a rough calculation I can use - for example, a group 10 car will cost 125 per cent more to insure than a group 1 car?

Asked on 16 February 2018 by Graham

Answered by Tim Kelly
No, there is no rough calculation. Insurers advise us it is a vastly complex process of underwriting based on many different algorithms, which are way to complex for you or I to understand. Alternatively, they choose to be opaque and would dread to be transparent in how they actually arrive at a premium. When challenged, they advise they will not disclose the process as this could put them at a commercial disadvantage. Yet, I cannot see how it can if they arrive at similar premiums.
Tags: insurance
Similar questions
Is it okay for someone else to drive my car while I'm serving a disqualification, or is the insurance void as it's only insured for me to drive? Can someone with third party cover on their insurance policy...
What do I have to do to put my Cat S car back on the road?
If you drive another car but it has got no insurance, does yous insurance cover you to drive it?
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 10% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ10 to save on an ALA policy

See offer