Brexit - Honestjohn

We might as well have a Brexit thread to bring up the various issues that the leave voters hadn't thought through and that Backroomers may have solutions for. It could get b***** in here. For example, in the unlikely event that Scotland has a second referendum, votes for independence and manages to stay in the EC, England loses its nuclear deterrent because the submarine base is in Scotland. If the Eurotunnel UK border is moved from Calais to Folkestone and the French simply let truckloads of migrants emigrate to the UK, it won't be possible to send them back.

Brexit - brum

This is a motoring discussion forum. Not a place to moan about democracy and it's consequences.

Brexit - mss1tw

This is a motoring discussion forum. Not a place to moan about democracy and it's consequences.

Is this not the ideal time to talk about the possible end of Euro emissions targets and all their ramifications on innocent motorists? ;)

Not to mention the endless safety and design regs.

(I'm not saying I disagree with progresses in safety etc. I'm saying if I want to buy a new car without ABS/TC etc etc etc, why should I not be allowed to do so?

Edited by mss1tw on 26/06/2016 at 12:20

Brexit - madf

This is a motoring discussion forum. Not a place to moan about democracy and it's consequences.

Is this not the ideal time to talk about the possible end of Euro emissions targets and all their ramifications on innocent motorists? ;)

Not to mention the endless safety and design regs.

(I'm not saying I disagree with progresses in safety etc. I'm saying if I want to buy a new car without ABS/TC etc etc etc, why should I not be allowed to do so?

So when we produce cars after Brexit, we will ignore EU regulations and sell no cars in Europe.

What a novel way of doing buiness.

Brexit - mss1tw

So when we produce cars after Brexit, we will ignore EU regulations and sell no cars in Europe.

Where did I say we should produce no EU compliant models? Let me know please.

I wonder if the Mondeo as a 'World Car' has one version that meets every reg, everywhere, in the world.

I suspect not.

Edited by mss1tw on 26/06/2016 at 20:52

Brexit - madf

Where did I say we should produce no EU compliant models? Let me know please

"Is this not the ideal time to talk about the possible end of Euro emissions targets and all their ramifications on innocent motorists? ;)"

If you seriously think that UK car manufacturuers will find it economic to produce two versions of engines for UK and EC cars, then I suispect you are going to be sadly disappointed.

Edited by madf on 26/06/2016 at 22:30

Brexit - Bromptonaut

If you seriously think that UK car manufacturuers will find it economic to produce two versions of engines for UK and EC cars, then I suispect you are going to be sadly disappointed.

NoX is incontrovertibly causing ill-health. Unlike CO2 or Ozone depletion which are global NoX accumulates in area where it's emmitted. If vehicles outside your door pour out NoX it's you and your family that suffer.

Brexit - dadbif
We don't sell cars to Europe, foreign countries use our workforce to work in their factories, then they sell their cars, I think Morgan is the only truly British motor manufacturer left...

The U.K. workers can then spend their wages buying foreign goods, or buy coffee in coffee shops wherein our next generation serve "apprenticeships" as baristas

Brexit - dadbif
We don't sell cars to Europe, foreign countries use our workforce to work in their factories, then they sell their cars, I think Morgan is the only truly British motor manufacturer left...

The U.K. workers can then spend their wages buying foreign goods, or buy coffee in coffee shops wherein our next generation serve "apprenticeships" as baristas
Brexit - twitcherman

On a motoring topic, ISTR it was EU law which helped to abolish the large differences in list prices of new cars between the UK and our european neighbours, initially by allowing UK customers to order RHD cars from european dealers at the local price. I wonder if we'll see the return of the "UK mug punter premium" in due course?

Brexit - Trilogy.

.

Edited by Trilogy. on 28/06/2016 at 19:04

Brexit - Trilogy.

This is a motoring discussion forum. Not a place to moan about democracy and it's consequences.

brum, well said, I'll be making another post with regard to this thread shortly.

Brexit - Galaxy

"Project Fear" being used again! Shame on you, HJ. Cameron and Osborne have already tried that tac-tic; it failed miserably!

Make no mistake, we've done the right thing by voting "Leave" A little bit of uncertainty at present but that was always to be expected. In a couple of months time you won't hear very much about it at all.

I knew I'd be voting "Leave" even long before the EU Referendum was announced. I have no regrets whatsoever and know that time will tell we've certainly done the right thing.

The glass is half-full, not half-empty!

Brexit - John F

The glass is half-full, not half-empty!

Maybe, but is it now filling or emptying?

When my father was my age he had lived through two world wars, a major depression (not just a 'recession') and fifteen years of miserable post-2WW austerity - all because of a dysfunctional disunited sectarian jingoistic collection of self-important European nation states.

Brexit - craig-pd130

When my father was my age he had lived through two world wars, a major depression (not just a 'recession') and fifteen years of miserable post-2WW austerity - all because of a dysfunctional disunited sectarian jingoistic collection of self-important European nation states.

And so how will the UK separating itself to become a disunited sectarian jingoistic nation state help? It's not that simple anymore.

The current political landscape has moved on somewhat since 1945. We are buffeted by economic forces that we no longer have the power to withstand, following the erosion of our manufacturing base over the past 50 years, and the selling off of national assets over the past 40 years.

These are the root causes of our current problems, not the EU, immigration or any of the other issues that were bandied around during the referendum. UK politicians have done a great job of screwing this country themselves, without needing any external help.

Brexit - injection doc

Wow HJ ha*** statement.

The decision has been made by democratic vote.

Now its time to claim our country back, roll up our sleeves and get on with it

Hopefully now we can fly our british flag !with out fear of offending someone. be patriotic and believe in Great Britian. Hence why its called great.

No one know what will really happen yet, the money men normally make things worse as does the press.

It looks like Holland and italy and may be one or two others are now thinking about exit and may be Europe will have to re-think as a whole.

I didnt see the economy flying in Spain or Italy or France or Greece & having just visited a poor guy who lost his Business and house in Spain when the Euro was forced upon them and their economy gradually collapsed, he is now living in the UK ( he is Spanish )

we need to pull together, Talking doom & gloom wont fix things.

We are always mislead by polloticians & the media.Good example was last week with a virtual news blackout on the Channel tunnel fiasco and Coast guard running the channel with extra patrols and extra armed police to cope with riots and fighting and murders at the tunnel & Calais during the referendum week ! Only need to google Riots Channel tunnel.

Brexit - Wackyracer

"Project Fear" being used again! Shame on you, HJ. Cameron and Osborne have already tried that tac-tic; it failed miserably!

Make no mistake, we've done the right thing by voting "Leave" A little bit of uncertainty at present but that was always to be expected. In a couple of months time you won't hear very much about it at all.

I knew I'd be voting "Leave" even long before the EU Referendum was announced. I have no regrets whatsoever and know that time will tell we've certainly done the right thing.

The glass is half-full, not half-empty!

I feel the same, I was not swayed by the nonsense campaigns. I made my decision based on true data. I feel it was the right result.

If Scotland wishes to be a separate country and join the EU, I hope they have enough money of their own to pay for it all and not have to look to Westminster to pay it for them like they have been doing for as long as I can remember.

One thing that really shows is that the remainers thought they could never loose, have you ever seen such a bunch of sore loosers in your life?

Brexit - oldroverboy.

One part of all this amuses me.

"we are going to do the uk no favours in exit talks"

Where is the predicted bank/currency crash?

Don't want to sell me a german/italian/spanish etc car.. ok

Don't want me to buy Euro fruit/wine/veg?

Don't want me to holiday in europe, ok. ( can afford to fly further afield where my presence will be appreciated.)

Don't want me to buy aldi lidl goods ok.

As it is with the current situation I cannot drive to the "continent" as it is no longer safe to pass through northern france by any of the major routes by road or rail, so bypass it by air, and so on...

Did I not here one of the VW execs saying that they didn't want to lose our market....

Just for germany what is the total of their sales in the uk?

I have lived and worked in europe, speak french fluently and german and italian enough to get by day to day.

There will be problems ahead, Our Country will recover from the present bit of fuss.

Brexit - Wackyracer

I agree ORB, its all a storm in a tea cup being fabricated by a bitter, resentful fraction of the remainers who thought they would never lose.

On another forum I stated I didn't care if Germany don't want to sell us cars, as they would be the losers and I could go and buy a Volvo or Lexus. The best the idiot could reply with was "your Volvo is built in Belgium".

There is a whole world of alternatives out there. Does any of these Pro EU'ers realise that?

Brexit - Warning

How can you say that? We had the ERM crisis in the late 80s. Norman Lamont raised interest rates to 20%. We ended up with 10 years of recession. This is why, when the time came Britain sensibly did not join the Euro.

I am not a fan of the EU, but we are headed for a major recession (or depresssion). It all depends on the EU.

If I where Spain with 20% unemployment, I would not want the UK to get the trade deals, I would be looking at poaching UK companies to relocate to Spain...



Brexit - Engineer Andy

How can you say that? We had the ERM crisis in the late 80s. Norman Lamont raised interest rates to 20%. We ended up with 10 years of recession. This is why, when the time came Britain sensibly did not join the Euro.

I am not a fan of the EU, but we are headed for a major recession (or depresssion). It all depends on the EU.

If I where Spain with 20% unemployment, I would not want the UK to get the trade deals, I would be looking at poaching UK companies to relocate to Spain...



Warning - where do you think Spain gets a large proportion of its foreign income from? Tourism and fresh food sales. The UK is a very large market for both, and especially tourism. Do you really think they'd get away with cutting their nose off to spite the face for long? Who would bankroll the black hole left by that? Germany?

Given rising resentment of them having to do so in Greece (much smaller size in economic terms), do you really think they would do so again in a much larger nation, and perhaps others as well? There's no money left in the EU for additional bailouts without seriously affecting those 'giving' (not lending - they'll never get it back).

Brexit - bolt

One part of all this amuses me.

"we are going to do the uk no favours in exit talks"

Where is the predicted bank/currency crash?

Don't want to sell me a german/italian/spanish etc car.. ok

Don't want me to buy Euro fruit/wine/veg?

Don't want me to holiday in europe, ok. ( can afford to fly further afield where my presence will be appreciated.)

Don't want me to buy aldi lidl goods ok.

As it is with the current situation I cannot drive to the "continent" as it is no longer safe to pass through northern france by any of the major routes by road or rail, so bypass it by air, and so on...

Did I not here one of the VW execs saying that they didn't want to lose our market....

Just for germany what is the total of their sales in the uk?

I have lived and worked in europe, speak french fluently and german and italian enough to get by day to day.

There will be problems ahead, Our Country will recover from the present bit of fuss.

What happens if the government vote against it, I heard there are calls from some MP`s to vote against leaving?

Brexit - groaver

If Scotland wishes to be a separate country and join the EU, I hope they have enough money of their own to pay for it all and not have to look to Westminster to pay it for them like they have been doing for as long as I can remember.

One thing that really shows is that the remainers thought they could never loose, have you ever seen such a bunch of sore loosers in your life?

If Carlsberg did irony....

Like your view of the EU, the Westminster govt takes Scotland's oil money then hands some back to "spend wisely".

If Scotland leaves, it will take its money too.

Edited by groaver on 27/06/2016 at 01:39

Brexit - Engineer Andy

What money? Oil is well below the profit line for the forseeable future, and North Sea gas is rapidly running out (at least our share). Who do you think bailed out RBS? It wasn't the Scottish taxpayer.

Brexit - groaver

What money? Oil is well below the profit line for the forseeable future, and North Sea gas is rapidly running out (at least our share). Who do you think bailed out RBS? It wasn't the Scottish taxpayer.

Let me guess...the British govt who has used oil money to prop up finances for years?

Brexit - Engineer Andy

Oh please! We don't have that much of the stuff! The SNP relied on the oil price being well over $100 just to break even, let alone 'make Scotland rich'. Hence why they want to remin in the EU, to get all those nice handouts designed for 'poor' countries. Scotland's economy/population is 10x less than England's, so do the Maths. The UK is a SERVICE economy, not a manufacturing/engineering one. That stopped 35+ years ago.

Brexit - groaver

YOU do the maths!

5 million people in charge of their own assets would have had the ability to have set up a reserve like Norway.

We don't want handouts like you insult. Just the ability to be in charge of our own affairs.

Sound familiar?

Brexit - Engineer Andy

YOU do the maths!

5 million people in charge of their own assets would have had the ability to have set up a reserve like Norway.

We don't want handouts like you insult. Just the ability to be in charge of our own affairs.

Sound familiar?

Yes, but you (presumably you're a Scot) had your chance in 2014 and the country voted to stay within the UK. Everyone knew there would be another referrendum on the EU and the risk of leaving, and voted accordingly. Also, oil prices are low (gas running out too on our side of the North Sea) and will likely remain so for some time - no money coming in from that then to pay the bills, and no UK exchequer to bankroll defecit spending.

You can have another referrendum just because this week some people feel differently. A week ago, there was a much higher pecentage (in a poll) against independence. Once the dust has settled over Brexit, things may change again. Will you have another one each time opinion swings for or against? Or if a Scottish city votes against leaving the UK - will they remain as an 'enclave' as some idiot (bad loser) Remainers are advocating for London as well as Scotland?

I wonder, if Scotland does at some point vote again and do so how you wish, maybe the rest of the UK (and especially England) says you can, as long as you pay back the money we lent you to bail out RBS, and by the way - no Pound - you want the EU, use the Euro. And we won't underwrite any of your banks any more or budget deficits, as the SNP demand. You can't have your cake and eat it.

I fully expected some short-to-medium term pain for the UK if we voted out of the EU, but the long term gain would be far better, not just for us in the UK, but for the other EU nations, as a 'last chance' wake up call to change for the better before the 'Project' dies in an unedifying mess that would cause far more serious and long-term problems than Brexit will ever do.

Unlike some Remainers, I respect the decisions of the 48% who didn't vote Out and will try as best I can to accommodate them as far as possible, but you have to respect the decision overall, just as the one in your homeland in 2014.

Edited by Engineer Andy on 29/06/2016 at 01:18

Brexit - groaver

I'll vote to leave every time and take the finite reserves that aren't nearly so perilously low as some would believe.

I am happy for the respective governments to discuss the terms properly and I don't want your generous handouts or help.

I wish self determination for Scotland and let the remaining UK countries continue with their own agenda.

I also do respect the vote. It does not stop those like me striving to convince the others that Project Fear does not have to be realised.

Brexit - Warning

Just focussing on the result from Car manufacturing regions. For me the biggest surprise is the vote from Sunderland. (this is a copy from another thread).

Sunderland, which relies on a single employer Nissan voted 61.3% to leave the EU!!!.


Now the reason cars are made in the UK rather imported from Japan, is to avoid all the tarrifs. Nissan chose the UK rather then elsewhere in Europe!. Those jobs were created as a result of being in the EU. The Japanese often build factories where they have the most economic benefit. In this case, Nisssan chose Sunderland. I feel Nissan's loyalty has been kicked in the teeth. If the UK leaves the EU, it puts all our car manufacturing plants outside the EU and cars manufactured in the UK, would be subject to tariffs (until those trade deals are sorted out). It beggars belief why workers in car manufacturing regions would take a such a big risk?. Manufacturing jobs are a matter of pride for this country, but also hard won.


Nissan, Toyota, Honda could have built their plants anywhere in Europe, but they chose the UK.

I am not a fan of the EU and can understand why parts of the country would vote to leave, but the result from Sunderland is surprise and disappointment, as it is not facing a migrant crisis.

These car workers are putting their own jobs at risk and car manufacturers like Nissan would have to re-evaluate their future in the UK.

The things which really annoys me, is that If Nissan car workers have no loyalty to the Nissan, how can I "trust" a Nissan factory worker to build me a decent car? Is there any loyalty to me as a car buy? May the factory workers don't give a toss about the customer?. Would they build my car with due diligence? A car which is not plagued with faults?.


A Japanese Nissan worker would have never done this!

I have bought Nissan, largely because they were reliable and because my driver instructor had one and so was the first car I drove. I have lost failth in Nissan and I guess my gut instincts not to a buy Nissan Qashqai were right.

Some of the other car manufacting regions had similar results. See: www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-3660150/C...l

Brexit - Wackyracer

What is the point of your post Warning? You are not a fan of the EU but, you are upset that the people in the vicinity of a car plant voted to leave?

Why does the way a person voted have any bearing on the quality of a persons work? It does not, is the answer.

The votes were the feelings of the people, not how their employers told them to vote.

Brexit - Warning

"What is the point of your post Warning? You are not a fan of the EU but, you are upset that the people in the vicinity of a car plant voted to leave?

I am upset, because Nissan workers are putting their jobs in jeopardy. It puts Nissan's UK operations at risk, due to uncertainty. Nissan may have to relocate or transfer production elsewhere. We lost our car industry, this is a second chance. Especially, in an area such as Sunderland, which is reliant on a single major employer.


Why does the way a person voted have any bearing on the quality of a persons work? It does not, is the answer.

In this instance, it does. As Nissan bosses wrote to workers to explain the situation. It shows a due disregard, and tells me Nissan Sunderland workers don't take their job seriously. It shows a complate lack of loyalty.

If you employ someone who has pride, in their work and they do great work. But if someone shows two fingers to the boss, well it shows in the work.

It was on this forum, I read the Qashqai did not do so well in the reliability index. I spoke to a 2015 Qashqai owner who said he he issues with his new car and the dealer was unable to resolve it.

"The votes were the feelings of the people, not how their employers told them to vote."

A Soviet era leader once said "A person shouldn't s*** where he is about to eat."

Brexit - quizman

So you think we should vote how the Japanese tell us?

How is it that Ford closed the Transit factory in Southampton and opened it in Turkey with EU money?

British people worked at the Transit factory making vans and paid their taxes. Some of these taxes went to the EU and they used some of it to give to Turkey so they could make vans there. What sense is there in any of that?

The best thing we've done for many a year is to leave the undemocratic corrupt EU. Britain will prosper in the years to come, just watch it.

Brexit - Bromptonaut

The best thing we've done for many a year is to leave the undemocratic corrupt EU. Britain will prosper in the years to come, just watch it.

Hell of a gamble though.

Brexit - craig-pd130

The best thing we've done for many a year is to leave the undemocratic corrupt EU. Britain will prosper in the years to come, just watch it.

Undemocratic? You know we elect MEPs to represent our interests in Europe, yes? Corrupt? And of course, the UK government is a paragon of virtue.

Brexit - daveyjp
I think that post sums up the UKs problem with the EU.

We read any lies printed in our media and then repeat them as the truth. Some very basic Google searchs will give you the truth about Ford and Southampton,

The decision to close Southampton was a decision made by Ford. Ford have made vans in Turkey for decades, expanding a much larger factory and service the whole European market was the best option for Ford.

Finally the money wasn't 'given' to Turkey by the EU.
Brexit - Wackyracer

Why does the way a person voted have any bearing on the quality of a persons work? It does not, is the answer.

In this instance, it does. As Nissan bosses wrote to workers to explain the situation. It shows a due disregard, and tells me Nissan Sunderland workers don't take their job seriously. It shows a complate lack of loyalty.

Of course it does not, what a load of nonsense. So to take your job seriously did YOU vote the way your boss told you to?

If you employ someone who has pride, in their work and they do great work. But if someone shows two fingers to the boss, well it shows in the work.

It was on this forum, I read the Qashqai did not do so well in the reliability index. I spoke to a 2015 Qashqai owner who said he he issues with his new car and the dealer was unable to resolve it.

If a car is badly designed, the people assembling the parts in the factory cannot and do not have any bearing on it's reliability or durability.

Who is showing 2 fingers to their boss? Do you do everything your boss demands of you, which isn't part of your job description? If you do, you live in some dickensian world far from where I live.

"The votes were the feelings of the people, not how their employers told them to vote."

A Soviet era leader once said "A person shouldn't s*** where he is about to eat."

I could give you details of the CCCP to a much greater level of detail than you can imagine.

What you are describing is not a Soviet thing, It's something that Saddam Hussein did to his people. They voted how he told them to or else.

Brexit - Engineer Andy

Warning - Sound like to me you're a 'yes' man at work! You're boss can tell you how to go about your job, but outside of work he or she is an equal person to you in the eyes of the law and can't tell you how to vote or coerce you on way or the other.

Just as a long line of so-called experts and celebs have been either (defacto IMO) bribed, coerced or have a personal/financial/political vested interest in the UK staying in (never minding the consequences to everyone else), I'd have rather heard from people giving an honest opinion as to their view and experience of what may happen either way, not what suits them for selfish reasons, or they've been told to say for one reason or another.

Very few such opinions were voiced during the campaign, and as someone who considered both sides of the argument for a long time, and wasn't swayed by the lies and threats (mainly on the Remian side, but some [including some by Farage on the Leave side]) - I don't take kindly to such behaviour (quite a British trait), I stand by my decision to vote to leave last Thursday.

If we had not been lied to again and again by both our own (mostly useless) politicians and those from the EU about what this country actually signed up for, the direction they wanted the EU to go (i.e. a free trade bloc with decent co-operation in other areas of mutual interest, such as security and the environment - NOT the creation on the sly of a European state and central government, making the UK parliament like a County Council, with no democratic way of removing those in charge at EU level) and no corruption in spending across the board/pathetic foreign affairs/Euro farce, I might've voted to stay in. Sadly that was patently NOT the case.

All this is both a wake-up call/slap in the face and a final warning to the other EU politicians and Commission to either seriously change the direction, style and conduct of the EU or it will collapse. Forcing nations and peoples together that aren't all on the same wavelength, or for that matter, that friendly towards one another is akin to forcing a warring couple to stay married: only disaster will be the result without a divorce and a mutual distance and respect for each other's opinions.

We may eventually have a proper European government (still with nations), but unless and until all these other problems have been resolved, both internally in each nation and regionally, nothing good can come out of a forced-together bloc. I suspect even this were to happen, it wouldn't do so for at least 100 years, possibly more.

Too many problems have been (artificially) swept under the proverbial carpet in pretending all the EU nations get on like they love each other, so perhaps they can start to address them in a grown-up and rational way. I somehow doubt it at the moment - not enough level-headed people in charge/putting themselves up for politicial office, and too many who do are either 'vanilla'/Blairite/corrupt/extremist candidates who are more content to serve themselves or extreme ideas.

Edited by Engineer Andy on 26/06/2016 at 18:00

Brexit - daveyK_UK

Just focussing on the result from Car manufacturing regions. For me the biggest surprise is the vote from Sunderland. (this is a copy from another thread).

Sunderland, which relies on a single employer Nissan voted 61.3% to leave the EU!!!.


Now the reason cars are made in the UK rather imported from Japan, is to avoid all the tarrifs. Nissan chose the UK rather then elsewhere in Europe!. Those jobs were created as a result of being in the EU. The Japanese often build factories where they have the most economic benefit. In this case, Nisssan chose Sunderland. I feel Nissan's loyalty has been kicked in the teeth. If the UK leaves the EU, it puts all our car manufacturing plants outside the EU and cars manufactured in the UK, would be subject to tariffs (until those trade deals are sorted out). It beggars belief why workers in car manufacturing regions would take a such a big risk?. Manufacturing jobs are a matter of pride for this country, but also hard won.


Nissan, Toyota, Honda could have built their plants anywhere in Europe, but they chose the UK.

I am not a fan of the EU and can understand why parts of the country would vote to leave, but the result from Sunderland is surprise and disappointment, as it is not facing a migrant crisis.

These car workers are putting their own jobs at risk and car manufacturers like Nissan would have to re-evaluate their future in the UK.

The things which really annoys me, is that If Nissan car workers have no loyalty to the Nissan, how can I "trust" a Nissan factory worker to build me a decent car? Is there any loyalty to me as a car buy? May the factory workers don't give a toss about the customer?. Would they build my car with due diligence? A car which is not plagued with faults?.


A Japanese Nissan worker would have never done this!

I have bought Nissan, largely because they were reliable and because my driver instructor had one and so was the first car I drove. I have lost failth in Nissan and I guess my gut instincts not to a buy Nissan Qashqai were right.

Some of the other car manufacting regions had similar results. See: www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/news/article-3660150/C...l

I hate to break it to you, but the work force at the Nissan plant in Sunderland is a small proportion of the city of sunderlands total voting population. Furthermore, not all of the workforce live in the Sunderland area. Please think these assertions through before your post, the generalisation in your scenario is comical
Brexit - RT

We might as well have a Brexit thread to bring up the various issues that the leave voters hadn't thought through and that Backroomers may have solutions for. It could get b***** in here. For example, in the unlikely event that Scotland has a second referendum, votes for independence and manages to stay in the EC, England loses its nuclear deterrent because the submarine base is in Scotland. If the Eurotunnel UK border is moved from Calais to Folkestone and the French simply let truckloads of migrants emigrate to the UK, it won't be possible to send them back.

England won't lose it's nuclear bases - they're on Crown property and the Scots would retain the monarchy, it's descended from the Scottish king James VI when England ran out of heirs.

If the English border is at the ports, migrants will be deported straight back to France - we can't do that now because of the EU.

IMO it's the Remainers who haven't thought things through.

Brexit - quizman

You're right RT, Scotland couldn't join the EU because it hasn't got the money to pay in. That is of corse if we are not daft enough to keep sending them our money.

The EU only want the UK to stay is because we pay so much in to help all the struggling EU members.

Bob Geldof was once right when he said "give us yer b****y money" That's all they want, certainly not our ideas- they have rejected us 70 times out of 70.

Brexit - daveyK_UK
The U.K. Calais boarder deal is between Britain and France, it has nothing to do with the EU.

Likewise the Eire and UK boarder deal has nothing to do with the EU.

Please do your research
Brexit - Bromptonaut
The U.K. Calais boarder deal is between Britain and France, it has nothing to do with the EU. Likewise the Eire and UK boarder deal has nothing to do with the EU. Please do your research

Yes, but a deal between two nations in the EU. If we're committed to floating off on our own and bu**ering up the EU it's no surprise if France says get stuffed.

Brexit - Avant

As HJ no doubt suspected, this thread has shown that there are no easy answers to the questions. And that's the point, isn't it - because there are no easy answers, the question shouldn't have been asked in the first place. What we now have is a result where by and large the baby-boomer generation - mine - has gambled with our children's and grandchildren's futures.

In the 1975 vote, my father, a Fleet Air Arm war hero, voted to stay in what we then called the Common Market. He said it went against his basic instincts, but he voted that way because he thought that we needed economic co-operation as well as the protection of NATO membership to prevent war in Europe.

I sympathise with the feelings of the Brexit supporters, and there is a lot wrong with the EU. But I was a slightly reluctant Remain voter as I'm risk-averse and still think the risks are too dangerous. David Cameron didn't need to call this referendum: he could have won the last election without it. As Winston Churchill once said - I forget about whom - he is like a cow that's given a good pail of milk - and then kicked it over.

Edited by Avant on 26/06/2016 at 22:55

Brexit - NARU

What we now have is a result where by and large the baby-boomer generation - mine - has gambled with our children's and grandchildren's futures..

Some interesting stats from Sky Data:

https://twitter.com/...700869656256512

Proportion who voted: 18-24: 36%, 65+: 83%

For young people saying that they were done over by the old, they need to look more towards their own age group. If more 18-24s voted, and if they voted in the same proportions as those who did, we'd have had a different result.

Here's a second source, says similar:

https://twitter.com/...567426117074944

Brexit - Engineer Andy

Indeed - I suspect the vast majority of young people who didn't vote were only concerned about two things on the day - 1. Which political party is going to pay for their 3 year 'holiday' at uni (so nothing to do with the vote), and 2. "Is the student Union open yet? I want a drink!!" Everything else pales into insignificance...

Brexit - Bromptonaut

Indeed - I suspect the vast majority of young people who didn't vote were only concerned about two things on the day - 1. Which political party is going to pay for their 3 year 'holiday' at uni (

Do you ever speak to young people Andy?

I have a couple of colleagues in their twenties. One very is very politically aware and voted Clear from what she says though that she's from a politicaly active family. Another, a law graduate aiming for the Inns of Court, and now around 24 told me she's never voted. Questioning revealed complete disengagement from the process. Simply doesn't see anything offered as relevant to her. Says many of her friends are the same.

Brexit - Engineer Andy

Indeed - I suspect the vast majority of young people who didn't vote were only concerned about two things on the day - 1. Which political party is going to pay for their 3 year 'holiday' at uni (

Do you ever speak to young people Andy?

I have a couple of colleagues in their twenties. One very is very politically aware and voted Clear from what she says though that she's from a politicaly active family. Another, a law graduate aiming for the Inns of Court, and now around 24 told me she's never voted. Questioning revealed complete disengagement from the process. Simply doesn't see anything offered as relevant to her. Says many of her friends are the same.

Yes I do, and to be frank most are concerned about other things (phones, hairstlyes, gossip, last night's footy, etc) in their lives and what happened on TV last night than politics, as long as the money keeps coming in. Citing two more 'grown up' young people doesn't equal the whole population. I also remember what it was like when I was that age, only 15-20 years ago. Not much has changed, except for the worse. Their 'disengagement' is no different to that of many people in society.

What they can't do is tell politicians that they alone should 'solve' all the UK's problems and not get off their own backsides to help. Most people are just content to rage at their TV/PC/attend the occasional protest and do nothing afterwards. Yes, politicians are doing a very bad job, but at least they've put their heads above the proverbial parapet to do something, which is more than I can say for most people, especially the young.

Brexit - gordonbennet

Would you believe it, log in timed out after i'd typed out the longest post i've ever wished to put here, most of you will be relieved at that i have no doubt.

This is worth a read though.

johnpilger.com/articles/why-the-british-said-no-to...e

Brexit - gordonbennet

This is quite amusing, taken from Liberal Vision blog.

“People are sick and tired of parties not doing what they say they will do after elections… for example the hated regime of my predecessor… And that is why we must put that legacy behind us… by not respecting the result of this election… or the one in 2015 that led to this election… where the foolish Prime Minister, made a promise, and kept it.

No... those were not real elections… they were elections marked by lies… dirty, dirty, filthy lies… told by dirty filthy liars… who are probably racists… or nazis… or nazi racists… who hate democracy… that is why these stolen votes… stolen by dirty, filthy nazi, racists, who stereotype other people with their hate and prejudice… cannot be allowed to count…

On our side who reasonably pointed out the risks of world war 3… the end of western civilisation… and that jobs were at risk.

These were hard facts… Look the PM has already lost his job… Well at least he will do in October… And Jeremy Corbyn should do… That’s almost 3 million already.

What is important is that need to have another election…. An election for decent clever people that gets the right result…
An election where only experts will be allowed to make the case… experts from places where decent clever people live… like Islington… or much further afield… like Camden… We need diversity of opinion… from people thinking for themselves… all saying the same thing.

It is only through this process… that we can restore trust in politics… and politicians… except the ones I just called dirty filthy liars… who cannot be trusted…

To the Electoral Commission comrades… we must seize the means of the ballot from the hated Government of dirty lying promise keepers.”

Brexit - Wackyracer

How interesting GB, so in this persons view only people who wish to remain must be allowed to vote. That sounds like real democracy to me.

Brexit - scot22

I was very disappointed to read your post Engineer Andy. No wonder young people disengage if they read views like that.

I have had a lot of contact with students, and still have contact with young people. The vast majority are enthusiatic, hard working and idealistic. Personally, I'm just jealous of their energy ! They deserve respect.

Brexit - Engineer Andy

I was very disappointed to read your post Engineer Andy. No wonder young people disengage if they read views like that.

I have had a lot of contact with students, and still have contact with young people. The vast majority are enthusiatic, hard working and idealistic. Personally, I'm just jealous of their energy ! They deserve respect.

Some are idealistic and energentic, but often are not experienced enough in the ways of the world, especially when it comes to being responsible for themselves and others (especially financially) and getting through hard times without the help of the 'Bank of Mum & Dad' or state handouts for their media studies course at college.

Its amazing how many completely change their opinions (especially political - I know many former school and college mates who have gone from significantly Left to Right of centre) when they reach their 30s. There's a whole world of difference between idealism and practical realism - that's what experience of the 'Uninveristy of Life' brings, not just life at Uni.

Brexit - gordonbennet

How interesting GB, so in this persons view only people who wish to remain must be allowed to vote. That sounds like real democracy to me.

A tongue in cheek post i suspect, poking much needed fun at the heavy irony, Lammy wouldn't get it, of the right sort of democracy ie his own election majority being good, whilst another sort of democracy ie referendum result bad....that attitude has been shining out from the wailing mob since the democracy they claim to believe in proved to be their undoing.

We have a political class and their elite and obnoxiously rich backers and media chums who for too long have made it as they go along to suit themselves, at long last, roughly 20 years and more, the electorate have finally said enough.

As for the young, maybe if they'd got off their pampered behinds and down the polling station the result would have gone their way, as it is those worn out oldies (being of working class background and association i know no-one who had this fabled golden working/pension life they envy so much) managed to hobble down to register their vote...better do your bit for your own fairy tale futures with the EU collective mummy providing all when we have the second ballot eh kids?

Maybe when they've done 50+ years of hard graft as many have and everything hurts they'll know why these oldies got their backsides out of bed and went and did their duty, it wasn't selfish reasons mainly it was experince teaching them what the youngsters do not know...and hopefully will never have to, a life of hard graft and being kicked in the cobblers at regular inervals by your suppposed betters.

Edited by gordonbennet on 27/06/2016 at 12:03

Brexit - Wackyracer

As for the young, maybe if they'd got off their pampered behinds and down the polling station the result would have gone their way, as it is those worn out oldies (being of working class background and association i know no-one who had this fabled golden working/pension life they envy so much) managed to hobble down to register their vote...better do your bit for your own fairy tale futures with the EU collective mummy providing all when we have the second ballot eh kids?

Maybe when they've done 50+ years of hard graft as many have and everything hurts they'll know why these oldies got their backsides out of bed and went and did their duty, it wasn't selfish reasons mainly it was experince teaching them what the youngsters do not know...and hopefully will never have to, a life of hard graft and being kicked in the cobblers at regular inervals by your suppposed betters.

Very well said GB. I voted to leave and no matter how many re runs they insist on, I'll keep voting to leave.

Brexit - John F

This is worth a read though.

johnpilger.com/articles/why-the-british-said-no-to...e

Good gracious, is JP still around pilgerizing away in his inimitable fashion? I thought he was dead.

This has been an interesting debate focusing on the economic arguments, but the real reason for the 'leave' result is the disturbing and unsettling effect of excess uncontrolled immigration upon the hundreds of cities, towns and villages of provincial England. Unlike the USA of 100yrs ago, England is perceived as being full, overcrowded and incapable of further expansion. Immigrants might well contribute more to the exchequer than the benefits they receive, but this is at the expense of the indigenous population who have no special talents or qualifications - i.e. ordinary people to whom the chattering middle classes hardly ever relate in any depth (e.g.Gordon Brown and his 'bigoted woman').

Brexit - RT

David Cameron didn't need to call this referendum: he could have won the last election without it. As Winston Churchill once said - I forget about whom - he is like a cow that's given a good pail of milk - and then kicked it over.

I disagree - promising an in/out referendum was the only way of keeping the Tory party together to win the election - and we can see over the weekend what chaos there would have been if the Tories hadn't won.

IMO Cameron expected to get much bigger concessions from the EU in his reform negotiations, which would have been enough to carry a Remain majority - but as it was, he got a fraction of b*****-all, which is why those sitting on the fence, like me, voted Leave.

Brexit - gordonbennet

Ho ho, see BoJo has taken the first steps to ensure his own election as leader by proposing associate membership including free movement of people.

No wonder they kept Farage at arms length, going to be a very interesting general election next time, and some people thought UKIP were now redundant....the tory's quandry now is do they call an immediate general election whilst Labour are beusy shooting themselves in the foot, but risk UKIP picking up the millions of natural labour voters who wanted OUT.

Or do they wait till 2020 by which time Labour might have found themsleves a leader with a principle, but by which time the deception of the tory Leave campaign will be clear to all.

Interesting time ahead.

Brexit - concrete

I agree with earlier posts. This is thread for general Discussion, as has been the case for some time since the referendum was announced.

I repeat my comments on the GD section.

We have had the referendum!

The people have made their choice!

Now 'man up' and live with it!

It seems that remainers wanted democracy, as long as it delivers the result they wished. Well, tough. get over it and get on with it.

Cheers Concrete

Brexit - daveyjp

Once the froth has gone and the negotiations begin there will be more fudge than on the shelves at Thorntons.

Already there is talk of the Norway model.

Gibraltar in paticular is a thorny issue and they may end up with a special deal, based on exceptional circumstances aka Denmark and Faeroes.

If Gib negotiate a special membership, then Scotland will be baying for the same.

Lots of mess to come!

Brexit - Honestjohn

Well said, RT. The villain of the piece is Jean Claude Juncker. When Cameron couldn't get a decent deal it became impossible to sell it to the nation with the conviction that was needed. Just like de Gaulle's "non" of 1963 and 1967, Juncker basically kicked us out and must bear full responsibility for the effect of that. He's not very popular in Germany. (Meanwhile, the average English person seems to be more upset about losing a football match.)

Edited by Honestjohn on 28/06/2016 at 10:25

Brexit - Bromptonaut

Well said, RT. The villain of the piece is Jean Claude Juncker. When Cameron couldn't get a decent deal it became impossible to sell it to the nation with the conviction that was needed. Just like de Gaulle's "non" of 1963 and 1967, Juncker basically kicked us out and must bear full responsibility for the effect of that. He's not very popular in Germany. (Meanwhile, the average English person seems to be more upset about losing a football match.)

The Juncker/Cameron issue is (arguably) a symptom of latter's failure to engage diplomatically with Europe during the coalition era. Cameron set out, against the majoroty view, to oppose Juncker's appointment to point of trying to veto.

Brexit - concrete

As a follow up to my previous post, about 10 minutes ago, let me say this.

To some extent I agree with HJ that there are certain issues that the referendum debate did not drill down to. That was because what actually passed for 'debate' was a pathetic propaganda, scaremongering excercise which did little or nothing to enlighten the issues. May I suggest that through the General Discussion section that HJ put forward one point per week to receive the benefit of our collective wisdom?

Let us start with Faslane. That would, over a period of time be transfered to another location in England or Wales. This was brought up during the Scottish independance referendum. As part of any seperation the timetable would be agreed between the relevant governments. This would of course leave Scotland and that particular area much poorer economically, but if that is their wish, so be it. The military facilty in Faslane contributes hundreds of millions of pounds into the Scottish economy, which they would of course lose. Which would probably mean local taxation to replace the revenue. This source of revenue would then of course be included into the English or Welsh economy, so a bonus for wherever the facility is relocated to. I know a lot of Scots, including relatives in that area, who would be devastated if the base were to close. They voted against independance for that very reason. Their livelyhoods are more important to them than any moral high ground about nuclear armaments, which is understandable. This, however, is not the case amongst the 16 to 19 year olds and causes rifts in families, principles can be expensive things, but it comes down to who and what puts bread on the table. Cheers Concrete

Brexit - oldroverboy.

Policing shadow minister Jack Dromey resigns, becoming the 42nd Labour frontbencher to quit in just 18 hours.

just as I write this, the fallout from the vote is that 42 labour mps have now resigned from Mr C's shadow cabinet.

If they are so principled let them resign from parliament and trigger 42 by-elections and see which way their electorate in their own seats would vote.

Never going to happen is it?

Brexit - RT

Corbyn's problem is that he's supported by the party activists who are totally unelectable at a general election - most labour MPs have a more moderate view - that's the problem with any political party that lets rank-and-file members elect the parliamentary leader.

Brexit - gordonbennet

Maybe if Labour MP's returned to representing, instead of telling them how to think, their natural voters the genuine working class that is, this crisis wouldn't be happening.

We are living through a period of history in the making.

Brexit - oldroverboy.

Maybe if Labour MP's returned to representing, instead of telling them how to think, their natural voters the genuine working class that is, this crisis wouldn't be happening.

We are living through a period of history in the making.

Ditto!

Brexit - Bromptonaut

If they are so principled let them resign from parliament and trigger 42 by-elections and see which way their electorate in their own seats would vote.

Never going to happen is it?

What a strange rationale.

They have an issue with their party leader whom they regard as a managerial disaster and electoral liability*. They have therefore resigned from his shadow cabinet/front bench. Nothing to with any matter of public policy except part of case for 'prosecution' his failure to engage with the IN campain.

The nearest analogy is the Tory ministers in 1990 who told Maggie it was time to go.

* As a lifelong supporter of the left I agree with them.

Brexit - oldroverboy.

If they are so principled let them resign from parliament and trigger 42 by-elections and see which way their electorate in their own seats would vote.

Never going to happen is it?

What a strange rationale.

Is it?

They do not wish to serve under the current leader. They may well be deselected by the forces of momentum and the unions.

Why not provoke a real debate, and if the unions do not select them let them stand as independents.

The electorate in their constituancy could then choose if that is the person they really want to represent them or if they want a yes man/woman.

I was a traditional labour voter till the 1979 election following on the winter of discontent, and after that worked outside the uk for more than 20 years, noting the increasing lunacy of some peoples policies, saying I won't get fooled again in 1997..

The current rabble reminds me of the bullying of the EU who will squeeze till it hurts to get a re-run referendum to get the result they want. They have got form...

Edited by oldroverboy. on 27/06/2016 at 19:59

Brexit - Oli rag

I feel that if the UK's infrastructure had kept pace to cope with the increasing population, a lot of people may well have bee inclined to vote remain.

Since 1997 when an open border policy was adopted, we've all suffered from ever crowded roads, hospitals, doctors waiting rooms and schools.

A lot more youngsters voted remain than leave and I suspect it's because they haven't had the problems of trying to get their children in to a local school or book regular appointments to see a doctor.

Very surprised to see the statistic that only 36% of 18 to 24 year old's bothered to vote.

Brexit - Bromptonaut

Since 1997 when an open border policy was adopted, we've all suffered from ever crowded roads, hospitals, doctors waiting rooms and schools.

A lot more youngsters voted remain than leave and I suspect it's because they haven't had the problems of trying to get their children in to a local school or book regular appointments to see a doctor.

Very surprised to see the statistic that only 36% of 18 to 24 year old's bothered to vote.

Youngsters voted remain because moving internationaly for work, study etcis as much part of their lives as their I-phones. They queue for the Doctor like everyone else. The person in front of them is their great-grandma......

Getting into local schools and the dodges/house price bingo to do so was going on in the seventies.

Brexit - sandy56

Our young adults and teenages are a bunch of spoled brats. The vote was for UK to exit the EU nothing else.

The majority vote was to LEAVE and approx 17 milllion people voted for this. A few noisy baby adults cannot change this.

On another related topic in my early twenties I worked acroos the world -from Norway, Germany, Netherlands to Mexico and USA, UAE to IRAN. We weren't in the EU, that came later. Being outside the EU federal state does not mean you cannot travel or work there. Last time I looked there was a lot of Americans Canadians Indians working in the EU, and those countries are NOT members of the EU.

Young people need to check their facts before these crazy, baseless theories start getting out of hand, maybe they need to look up from their iphone to actually look at the real world and not just Facebook.

PS I am sure BMW VAG and Mercedes will be quite happy to continue selling us cars after we leave, and that will obviously be reciprocated.

Keep Calm and Carry On.

Brexit - Trilogy.

************************************************************

I'm appalled that HJ doesn't know the different sections of his forum. This topic should be in the General Discussion forum. If anyone other than the OP had started this in Motoring discussion I'm one moderator in particular would have moved the thread PDQ. Given the OP stated 'it could get b***** in here' it was quite clearly an extremely provocative statement aimed at inciting the users of this website. I get the feeling this topic was deliberately placed in this section to extract the greatest response.

The OP and moderators should hang their heads in shame, especially one moderator, who I would certainly have expected know better. As long as this thread stays in 'Motoring discussion' the HJ site has absolutely no credibility, and indeed makes a mockery of it. I have unsubscribed from the emailed HJ newsletter.

I wonder if certain individuals will apologise for their actions or indeed lack of. No doubt they will have alienated some backroomers, who I suspect will never return.

**************************************************************************

Brexit - Avant

I'm surprised, Trilogy: normally your posts are full of common sense. It's hardly a matter of great importance which section of the forum a thread goes in, and certainly not something to be 'appalled' at.

I'm sure HJ put it in this section, as you say, to extract the greatest response, as more people look in this section. We are a reasonable cross-section of people on here, and I'm glad that the discussion has evoked plenty of interest, stayed polite and been respectful of opposing views. And as it's HJ's forum he is the best judge of where to put a thread! The issue certainly affects us as motorists, after all.

For myself I was a slightly reluctant supporter of Remain, and the events of the past few days seem to have made my point that the risks of upheaval weren't worth taking. But I completely respect those who disagree, and understand their reasons.

Brexit - Wackyracer

I have to agree Sandy, that is how I see it myself.

We could do soo much but, our leaders are frightened to detach themselves from the EU mummy's apron strings.