Site link to phishing emails [Read Only] - adverse camber
This morning I've received two fake paypal emails. Nothing so unusual there you might think. However I use one-off email addresses and the two that have been targetted this morning have only been used to register with the HJ site.

That makes me suspect that the site has suffered a data loss. When the site was hacked a little while ago did the attackers get a list of subscribers email addresses?

Subject line changed slightly following an e-mailed suggestion

Edited by Dynamic Dave on 23/06/2009 at 14:52

phishing emails - Halmer
me too.
phishing emails - Alby Back
Yup.
phishing emails - Armitage Shanks {p}
Me too!
phishing emails - Falkirk Bairn
me too!
phishing emails - bobincharente
I received 2 this weekend - one from paypal and one from Cahoot - both were very amateur

Bob
phishing emails - buzbee
I got one.
phishing emails - Pugugly
I'll alert Stephen.
phishing emails - adverse camber
Thanks Rob.

I know that in this case it was a rather poor attempt, but there are now some quite high quality phishers out there. Given that I feel 99.9% certain that this has originated from the site list I thought it was worth raising.

One of those addresses was used to register an account from a workplace some time ago, so I'm pretty sure it had minimal use and hasn't even swapped mails with any of the mods.

the addresses in question are only used for hj.

Edited by adverse camber on 21/06/2009 at 13:11

phishing emails - nick
Me too, a paypal one this morning although my address on here is also used on other forums too, but not displayed
phishing emails - Lud
Ah, that's what those were. I dumped them of course without opening them. Spam is spam.
phishing emails - JH
I've had a very amateur Paypal phishing email this morning but then I frequently do. The way email delivery works I very much doubt you can blame this site. The email addresses are generated and thrown out to see what sticks. That's why you should never reply - you confirm that a real email address has been found.
JH
phishing emails - Hamsafar
Me too, Cahoot and Paypal with strange character accents.

You have a new security message From Cahoot Bank Plc .
Log on
Yours sincerely,
Online Customer Service
Cahoot Bank

-----------
service@int.Päypäl.com
ear Päypäl Customer,
This e-mail is to inform you of a recent update we have made to oursystems.
To avoid service interruption we require that you confirm
your account as soon as possible. Please click here and take a
moment to confirm your account.
Please follow the following steps:
SNIP

Edited by Hamsafar on 21/06/2009 at 11:26

phishing emails - RobertyBob
Me too, both Cahoot & Paypal.
phishing emails - henry k
Me too both Cahoot & Paypal.

>>
And me too.
(Just checked my spam box )

I have never had any before.
phishing emails - merlin
When a site is broken into the email address list is targetted because it can be sold on to spammers. Typically these addresses will be real and active.

I recently gave a one off very specific email address to a very large car company to download a brochure. This used a domain I own. No one else knows this email address. I'm now seeing ~5 spam per day sent to this same email address. I cannot believe that the car company would give my email address to spammers willingly so it appears their mailing list has been compromised. I'm not seeing any spam sent to randomly generated email addresses on my own personal domain.

Edited by merlin on 21/06/2009 at 11:43

phishing emails - bell boy
just checked,ive got the paypal one too now
i reported the cahoot one the other day on the computer questions thread,seems by blaming the car parts finder set up i was wrong as quite correctly the email address i gave them was the one i use on here and is one of 6 i have with virgin

now then hj i want a big jam buttie as recompense
phishing emails - Mr X
I didn't get one......but then again, I direct all my emails to the trash drawer except for a chosen few.

Edited by Mr X on 21/06/2009 at 12:02

phishing emails - oilrag
Me too. The one and only spam yet received in my month old Google email account..
phishing emails - Stuartli
I've have both types in recent days and this morning - the PayPal example included Russian style letters in the Subject field.

For some reason that made me very suspicious...:-)

However, it's not the first time I've had them so can't blame this website.

Genuine e-Bay and PayPal e-mails are easily worked out.

Edited by Stuartli on 21/06/2009 at 12:16

phishing emails - Armitage Shanks {p}
I spot them Ok and forward them to spoof@paypal.co.uk to help them trace the originator.
phishing emails - cuthbert
me too

Fron Paypal from email address as above!! also this is the only place I use that email address
phishing emails - andyfr
I got one yesterday.
phishing emails - adverse camber
Actually JH I can.

The joy of owning your own domains and managing your own mail service is that you can invent mail addresses at the drop of a hat.

Everytime I have to give an email address to a company or web site, the address they get is of the form websitename@mydomain.org So I can always ID those who share. Yes I do see all the random ones as well. But in this case it is not random.
phishing emails - b308
I got one as well with those strange "a"s...
phishing emails - Clk Sec
Me too - both of them.

Clk Sec
phishing emails - ifithelps

The Cahoot one landed in my in-box and I thought looked quite professional - maybe I'm easily fooled.

The Paypal one with the Russian accents was sent straight to junk by hotmail.

Don't usually bother looking in junk, and since it's on 'auto delete' I could have had many others.
phishing emails - Martin Devon
And Moi.
phishing emails - ex-Triumph man
I also got this odd message from Paypal. However there was also an error message at the lower left hand corner of the screen.
Having read these warning from you good people, I pressed the "Block sender" button.
phishing emails - Martin Devon
it'll come again from a slightly different address.

MD
phishing emails - Simon
I've just checked my email and yes I have both the spoof Paypal and Cahoot ones. I must say that I am slightly annoyed by this as up until this point I have received almost no spam/spoof emails to my current main email address. I think that we have established beyond reasonable doubt that the Honest John site is to blame so am I now to expect a raft of spam to appear in my inbox daily? I am not amused!
phishing emails - Bromptonaut
Pay pal today and I'm fairly sure I deleted something fron Cahoot earlier in the week Email address is effectively on my own domain but it's the one I use for nearly everything so cannot blame this site.

Spam happens, no point in worrying about it.
phishing emails - TimOrridge
I
think that we have established beyond reasonable doubt that the Honest John site is to
blame so am I now to expect a raft of spam to appear in my
inbox daily? I am not amused!


Chill guys :) :) its only spam, take it as part of life. I'm sure HJ and Stephen will be looking at this and I'm sure all us BR's are all savvy enough to know a spoof email from a genuine one.

P.S I got one too! :)
phishing emails - jbif
Chill guys :) :) its only spam, take it as part of life. >>


Does your double smiley mean that you are joking? If so, this is not something to joke about.

IMO, it is a serious breach of confidentiality and privacy agreements you enter into with HJ's website when you sign on. Either the iste has been hacked and security of data creached, or the data sold without consent.

phishing emails - TimOrridge
No I wasn't joking, it makes no difference to me as I get spammed to death anyway. I've got more important things to worry about.

Edited by TimOrridge on 21/06/2009 at 18:46

phishing emails - stan10
Me too.
phishing emails - jbif
Me too. My email on this site is not used for any other purpose, and has been made known only to this site. So it is definitely points to the site having been hacked.

Both emails caught by my spam filter.

phishing emails - oilrag
It pales into insignificance for me - contrasted with the heap of spam I received from a certain last gasp holiday company when we bought tickets to the Far East.

Last gasp really piled them in so I sent formal complaints in (as unsubscribe had no effect) *taking their energy*.

They then had to respond formally each time a spam arrived. Funny that - they stopped dead shortly after. And yes, I did tick the box asking for no contact.

Should these emails be forwarded and diverted to Webmaster...;-)

Just a little Joke....... ;-)
phishing emails - KB.
Me too...... PayPal yesterday. First one I've ever had. Fairly amateur if you're vaguely aware but must catch a few by sheer weight of numbers.
phishing emails - mike hannon
We had one too. As it happens we don't have a Paypal account any more and I manage OK without. Never open anything like that anyway.
Some time ago we had an internet bank fraud (which was made good by the bank on condition we co-operated with a police investigation). The first question the police asked was 'do you use Paypal?'
phishing emails - Old Navy
And me, both cahoot and paypal. The email address is only used on this site. I dont have accounts with either outfits.

Edited by Old Navy on 21/06/2009 at 18:01

phishing emails - malteser
I'm so confident in Gmail's spam filters that I'm quite happy to post my email address on open fora, such as this!
I use Thunderbird as my email client, set to use Gmail's own SSL servers, thus bypassing my ISP's rubbish mail servers completely, so rarely log on to Gmail's web mail. I've just done so to check and I'm pleased to tell you I havent been left out!
The dodgy Paypal message was duly sitting in the spam folder there, along with 68 other various pieces of ordure. (I cleared out all the junk a day or so ago).
There have been occasions when there have been upward of 300 spam mails in the folder!
phishing emails - Honestjohn
Be a couple of weeks before we can get to the bottom of this. Meanwhile, don't open any dodgy looking e-mails.

I've been getting dodgy e-mails allegedly from paypal for years. Just bin them. Along with Fedmarket, Abbey National, HBSC and all the other obviously suspect garbage.

HJ

Edited by Honestjohn on 21/06/2009 at 19:27

phishing emails - seasiders rock
yep...me to. first for pay poo....hotmail sent it straight to junk.
phishing emails - R75
yep, same here, got the PayPal one today - not ever had a spam one from PayPal before, but lots of others.
phishing emails - jbif
I've been getting dodgy e-mails allegedly from paypal for years. Just bin them. >>


With all due respect, that is missing the point.

The point is this: people who have a private exclusive email address which is known to no one else other than the honestjohn web site are getting spam emails for the first time. This indicates that the HJ website has had its security compromised.

The spam emails are NOT the problem for the receipients here.

However, the breach of security should be a major concern for the owners or technical administrators of this web site. As the t&c states:
"Privacy policy
It is very important to us that you should be able to use and enjoy the website without your privacy being compromised in any way."

Edited by jbif on 22/06/2009 at 00:06

Site link to phishing emails - Andrew-T
Yep - a Cahoot and a Päypäl, both yesterday. Why the umlauts were put on the Paypal one I have no idea ...
Site link to phishing emails - bathtub tom
I didn't get any - yet. Why have I been left out?
Site link to phishing emails - Statistical outlier
I'm not sure how I would tell if I got them - I get about 100 spam emails a day to each of my accounts. Doesn't really bother me, Google gets rid of all of them for me.
Site link to phishing emails - 1400ted
I had one from Paypal as well.

Ted
Site link to phishing emails - Westpig
are you sure you lot haven't been looking at some Frankie Vaughan?...;-)
Site link to phishing emails - eProf

I got one too and had a look at the html coding behind the message.

The address behind the "click here to get screwed" is "http:**//smpdarmapatria-bks.sch.id/en/" which doesn't look PayPally! (The two ** I put in to stop the URL from working)

The source of the message is ns0.triad.uk.com which is listed as owned by LondonLink Hostmaster whose address I have. I do love "nslookup" and "Whois"!

eProf
Site link to phishing emails - RobertyBob
Two new ones overnight, both supposedly from Abbey.

Shame really as I don't usually get any Spam.
Site link to phishing emails - Honestjohn
eProf, assuming someone somehow broke in to Admin, collected every Backroomer's e-mail, then sold them to phishing gangsters, what is the answer?

Surely there isn't one apart from closing down the Backroom, everyone getting a new e-mail address, and starting again.

HJ

Edited by Honestjohn on 22/06/2009 at 10:14

Site link to phishing emails - Slow Eddie
Clearly that's correct, HJ. We live in a wicked world of spammers & have to get over it. I suppose we just have to read between your lines a little to make out: "Er, sorry about that, guys."
Site link to phishing emails - jbif
eProf, assuming someone somehow broke in to Admin, collected every Backroomer's e-mail >>


1. The first question is: How much data did the hackers get? Did they also get the passwords? If so, it is not such a big problem for those of us who have a dedicated email address for this site and/or are security savvy enough to use unique passwords for every web site we sign on to. The threat is to those who use a common email address and/or use the same email account and password for all their online activities and/or have weak passwords. Hackers could then access those email accounts and gather even more sensitive information.

2. The second question for the site admin is how did the breach happen? Could it be that the discarded server hard drives have ended up somewhere they should not have?
If you think that is far-fetched, see news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/8036324.stm

3. Thirdly, what can/should site admin do now? IMO, all backroomers should be asked/advised to change their password first, and then gradually over the coming days/weeks should also set up a new email address to log on here.

Edited by jbif on 22/06/2009 at 11:02

Site link to phishing emails - OldSock
Yep - a Cahoot and a Päypäl both yesterday. Why the umlauts were put on
the Paypal one I have no idea ...


Maybe the originators are 70's heavy metal fans ? :-)

Yes, I've had them too :-(
Site link to phishing emails - Honestjohn
jbif has made the best sense so far.

Obviously if Backroomers have used their main e-mail addresses to register then we can't ask them to change their e-mail addresses because this will involve turning their lives upside down.

We think this happened when the site got hacked. I have my suspicions about who was really behind it, but I can't prove anything so I'm not going to let on.

The admin is now double locked so it is unlikely it will get hacked again soon.

But obviously if a bunch of crooks has got hold of an e-mail address (which they could have done from anywhere) then they have it and that e-mail address will continue to get phishing e-mails and SPAM.

HJ
Site link to phishing emails - David Horn
A useful tip if you have a Gmail account is that you own the first part of the email address. So, if mine was "david@gmail.com", the email address "david+anything@gmail.com" is also mine.

So, when you register anywhere, using, say, "david+honestjohn@gmail.com" will instantly identify where you spam comes from.
Site link to phishing emails - adverse camber
Indeed Jbif is thinking on exactly the same lines as lines as I am.

The spam isn't the issue; in general spam is such a part of the normal internet experience that in itself it does not merit mention. It s all filtered and dealt with automatically anyway for most people.

The point is the implication that the site data has been obtained and the potential risks beyond that.

It may be that passwords are stored in a secure form (I hope so), and that there is no issue. I'd also be interested in how full the rebuild was after the hack and what the possibility is of backdoor being installed.

Does Stephen Khoo maintain seeds in the data? I've done this ever since my early days of marketing fulfilment. Ficticious Name/Address combos which are held only in the one dbase so that you can detect theft of the data. I used to use my parents address as unlikely to change in years.
Site link to phishing emails - Mapmaker
So, HJ, do you store passwords in encoded form, or is it likely that the hacker took those as well?
Site link to phishing emails - ifithelps
...and the potential risks beyond that....

The HJ site has my general correspondence email address and a unique 'strong' password for the backroom.

I imagine quite a few of us are in a similar position.

Spam, as adverse camber says, is a fact of internet life, but is there anything else I should be on the lookout for?
Site link to phishing emails - seasiders rock
update...in addition to the paypal e mail now have had 2 from the abbey...what fun.
Site link to phishing emails - cuthbert
Yes had one from Abbey today went into the spam folder this time !!

I know spam is a everyday problem but in my case I am very fussy who I give my email address too!!
I have never had spam before except on a tiscali address which I closed down
Site link to phishing emails - oilrag
I`ve just had the Abbey one - straight into Gmail spam - that`s only the second ever spam I`ve had in this account.

Had a minor panic just then and went through every other site I use (Amazon and so on) hoping I had not used the same password - no fortunately. But changed them all anyway while I was in there + a new exclusive password on this site.

That just leaves a newish Gmail account with a good, easy to remember front end picking up phishing scam for the first time.

What are opinions on what to do with this?

1) Keep it and leave it as HJ account too (as it already is.
2) Dump it and get a new main Gmail account + leave old account for HJ site.
3) Set up a temporary POP3 Virgin account to register - then void it.

It would really help to know if passwords were encrypted and what their future staus will be

4) Fuss about nothing - go to bed and forget about it??

Yawn ;-)


Site link to phishing emails - nick
I don't think passwords are encrypted or at least they weren't a few years ago. I forgot mine and a mod was able to tell me what it was.
Site link to phishing emails - eProf
oilrag: Option 4 - good thinking!

I have a system of using random email addresses based on my domain name which enables me to trace the source of any spam - I even had a stack which originated from a competition I entered on Waitrose.com.

Encryption is the answer! Have a look at www.Steganos.com where you will find several useful tools to keep personal information safe in your own computer.

ePr*f
Site link to phishing emails - Manatee
I'm pretty cheesed off by this, which has compromised a hitherto clean address - the Paypal email is the first spam received to this account - maybe I shouldn't have added it but it wasn't I who didn't keep it secure.

I would like an answer to the password encryption question, though I suspect I know it.

Why this site uses flaky homemade forum software when there is better, apparently more secure, and free stuff around with is another question.
Site link to phishing emails - BobbyG
HJ / Stephen,

Can you answer the specific question re passwords? Is someone out there now got all the email addresses and passwords for this website?
Site link to phishing emails - Manatee
I've now changed my email for this site to a much-spammed one, lest it be lost again, though the horse has bolted.

It would be a good idea to email the facts to all subscribers, primarily for the benefit of the many who will not have seen this thread and might have had their email and password compromised.

Woe betides any organisation that mislays customer data. Just be happy this site doesn't ask for your date of birth.
Site link to phishing emails - Dynamic Dave
Stephen, Can you answer the specific question re passwords?


I'm sure Stephen Khoo will provide some answers when he is back in the office on Wednesday or Thursday this week. DD
Site link to phishing emails - welshlad
do you mean to say i didnt really just win 25,000,000 on the australian lottery !!!!!!!!
Site link to phishing emails - Rattle
I can't say for this site, but certainly all the sites I have produced or worked on have had the passwords protected by means of MD5 hash. When you register a script changes the password you enter into a hash key. So the password which is stored is not your password but a hash key which is very very hard to reverse engineer. I cannot say for certain as I don't know ths specifics of this site, but I would guess your passwords are 100% secure unless you have spyware on your machine.

Also random spam generators are very easy to code, so if you have your email with one of the big providers like hotmail you will always get spam. If you have your domain it is harder but it is still fairly easy to guess new email addresses if you put an enough effort into generationg such a program.

Also if your address is visible spam pots would easily pick this up.

I know some companies are now turning to ASP.NET as they believe it is a lot less volunerable to attacks than PHP is. That said I still use PHP because its cheaper and so easy.

I remember in the old days I would spot security flaws all the time on the earliest database driven websites and I am no hacker but I can't remember the last time I spotted an obvious flaw (on any site) so things are getting a lot better.
Site link to phishing emails - oilrag
Is the existing forum part of the site ever going to be secure though - unless the Forum is shut down and restarted with every member having to provide new passwords?

Unless the forum software logs a posters IP address, what`s to stop the lost email addresses (and presumably passwords) being used maliciously by someone else. To post under the genuine members nick.

Where does that possibility leave genuine members - with reference to the sites policy on personal accountability on material posted?

Edited by oilrag on 23/06/2009 at 09:34

Site link to phishing emails - oilrag
You is a jerk oilrag yoo dunt no wat u talkin aboot - log into yoor bank ackount nowe on da sent emale.

(sorry ;-)
Site link to phishing emails - drbe
Is KeePass Password Manager software (which is free) any good?
Site link to phishing emails - HJ Commercial
Dear all,

Thank you for your comments and suggestions. We are taking this matter very seriously and have made improvements to our site security recently. We are looking into this matter further and will make a full announcement to all backroomers within 48 hours.

Many thanks

The HJ publishing team.

Site link to phishing emails - Mr X
How do we know you are the HJ publishing team...........
You could be the hacker,


Site link to phishing emails - Dynamic Dave
I think that's enough speculation for now. Let's wait for an answer.

DD.