Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V

Honest John Back Room » Technical matters
View Threaded
Sun 6 Jun 2010 22:22
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

I've been the satisfied owner of Cr-V's now over the last 7 years but now I've got a problem with my latest one which is a 2.2 Diesel with manual gearbox. I'm wondering if anyone else has experienced anything similar.

The problem is a noise, almost exclusively between 1500 and 2000 rpm and when under load, that my dealer is suggesting is an induction noise i.e. the air intake for the engine. It's not really a roaring noise, more like a rushing noise. For those a bit longer in the tooth (like me!) it's very similar to the noise you could experience on very high mileage rear wheel drive vehicles from the rear axle; only it's coming from the front. In fact the noise seems to be travelling up the gear lever. I've been experiencing it since I had 500 miles on the clock but then I did pussyfoot the engine for those first 500 miles so wouldn't have experienced it before then.

As a caravanner, when driving solo it's only there when accelerating fairly hard but when towing it's very annoying. It's right in the rev range that seems to be used nearly all the time and it's always under load.

My dealer acknowledges that there is a noise but tells me there is no other cases known to Honda and is reluctant to just start slapping new bits on without knowing the cause. He's having it back in this week for more investigation but I'd like to know if the problem is unique to my vehicle or not. I have already had a test drive in a similar vehicle with 15000 miles on the clock which didn't have the noise. This was with the workshop manager in the car with me and he agreed there was definately a noise in my car which wasn't present in this one.

We've ruled out the usual problem of the rear diff fluid.

One last thing, I'm averaging about the 40mpg on solo long runs. Is anyone getting much better? I used to get 45mpg in my previous one which was an '06 reg.

Any comments or info would be gratefully received.

Edited by tony h on 06/06/2010 at 22:24

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sun 6 Jun 2010 23:18
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Peter.N.

I take it this is a turbo diesel in which case you shouldn't be able to hear intake roar unless there is a hole in the in the ducting somewhere, then it would be a whistle rather than a roar and would affect the performance. A rushing noise could though point to a leak in the turbo output pipe.

Without hearing it I can only suspect the gearbox, possibly the layshaft bearings, I have an XM that that is noisey over a fairly narrow rev band and does it in all gears, worse when its hot, almost quiet cold. It has done nearly 200k miles but I had another one that was still quiet at nearly 300k

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 7 Jun 2010 12:33
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

Hi Peter, yes it is the turbo diesel ( i-CTDI). My concern is that it is the gearbox as you suggest. It's the dealer who thinks it's an intake noise. I think the dealer has to bite the bullet and rule it out if I'm going to keep the car.

Thanks for posting

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 7 Jun 2010 13:09
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Peter D

You say it is rpm related and load. Is it road speed related at all. I suggest the dealer disables the turbo and drives the car to see if the noise stops. Regards Peter

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 7 Jun 2010 17:22
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - dervdave

You say it is rpm related and load. Is it road speed related at all. I suggest the dealer disables the turbo and drives the car to see if the noise stops.

After a very quick glance at the question my first thoughts were `turbo whistle` but I supposed you already discounted that ?

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Tue 8 Jun 2010 14:19
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

Hi Peter D, It has absolutely no relation to road speed. Not actually heard it in 1st gear but it's there in all the other forward gears. Very distinct between 1500 and 2000 rpm under load. It's the same noise no matter how much load, but obviously the more load the longer it takes to get through that rev range.

Not sure how you'd disable the turbo and still have the engine run properly. Anyone any ideas on this?

Dervdave, definitly not turbo whistle, at least not of the normal variety!

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Tue 8 Jun 2010 16:17
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Peter D

The garage can disconnect the boost acuator and after testing and reconnecting they can clear the error fault that will b elogged. The turbo will still spin up but little boost so it may isolate the noise. Regards Peter

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Tue 8 Jun 2010 18:32
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - dervdave

Another stab in the dark, the noise would be the whoosh of a viscous fan would it ?

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Wed 9 Jun 2010 14:04
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

No Dave, no viscous fans, just twin electic. It's with the dealer today to see what they can come up with.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Wed 9 Jun 2010 17:12
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - dervdave

It's with the dealer today to see what they can come up with.

Keep us posted Tony

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sat 12 Jun 2010 23:17
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h
Just an update - It's still with the dealer! They've ordered a new turbo.
Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sun 13 Jun 2010 08:14
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - dervdave

Did they say what was wrong with the turbo ?

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Sun 13 Jun 2010 12:33
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Peter D

Now you know why I suggested disabling the boost. Regards Peter

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Wed 16 Jun 2010 21:47
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

Hi guys, it's back.

The new turbo has sorted it although the front diff had to removed to accomplish it so that has had a refill.

Dealer didn't say what was wrong with the turbo other than when comparing it with the GM's the turbo whistle was a bit more pronounced.

Thanks for your postings.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 17 Jun 2010 10:24
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - dervdave

Dealer didn't say what was wrong with the turbo other than when comparing it with the GM's the turbo whistle was a bit more pronounced.

Just one of those things eh ? pleased you`ve got it sorted and back Tony.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 2 Sep 2010 15:20
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - tony h

It's back - and I don't mean the car this time!

Only stayed quiet for about 100 miles then it's back to how it was, only a bit more so. Occurs over a wider rev range now but then I've put another 3.5k on the clock with my summer holiday.

Workshop manager at main dealer doesn't want to know so I've been speaking to Honda UK. Dealers now having it in on the 22nd of this month for another look but, quite honesly, I've had enough messing about. I can see a big argument on the horizon!

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 2 Sep 2010 15:31
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Peter D

Get them to disable the turbo and go for a run to see if the noise has actually stopped. Your problem may be the Diff and the oil refill eased your problem temporarily. Regards Peter

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Thu 2 Sep 2010 15:55
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - PETER 4768

If I were you, I would go to the dealer and test drive another similair vehicle, I think the noise your encountering is one that all the diesel crvs make.

regards Peter

Reply | Report as offensive | Link
Mon 31 Oct 2011 19:51
Honda CR-V - Unidentified Noise on a 59 reg Honda Cr-V - Audrey P.

I've been the satisfied owner of Cr-V's now over the last 7 years but now I've got a problem with my latest one which is a 2.2 Diesel with manual gearbox. I'm wondering if anyone else has experienced anything similar.

The problem is a noise, almost exclusively between 1500 and 2000 rpm and when under load, that my dealer is suggesting is an induction noise i.e. the air intake for the engine. It's not really a roaring noise, more like a rushing noise. For those a bit longer in the tooth (like me!) it's very similar to the noise you could experience on very high mileage rear wheel drive vehicles from the rear axle; only it's coming from the front. In fact the noise seems to be travelling up the gear lever. I've been experiencing it since I had 500 miles on the clock but then I did pussyfoot the engine for those first 500 miles so wouldn't have experienced it before then.

As a caravanner, when driving solo it's only there when accelerating fairly hard but when towing it's very annoying. It's right in the rev range that seems to be used nearly all the time and it's always under load.

My dealer acknowledges that there is a noise but tells me there is no other cases known to Honda and is reluctant to just start slapping new bits on without knowing the cause. He's having it back in this week for more investigation but I'd like to know if the problem is unique to my vehicle or not. I have already had a test drive in a similar vehicle with 15000 miles on the clock which didn't have the noise. This was with the workshop manager in the car with me and he agreed there was definately a noise in my car which wasn't present in this one.

We've ruled out the usual problem of the rear diff fluid.

One last thing, I'm averaging about the 40mpg on solo long runs. Is anyone getting much better? I used to get 45mpg in my previous one which was an '06 reg.

Any comments or info would be gratefully received.

Though this letter was posted year ago, but despite this I hope you could give me any suggestions.

I have Honda CR-V of the same model (2.2 diesel with manual gearbox) and it makes the same noise as you described earlier between 1500 and 2000 rpm and when under load. Did you clarified the reason of this problem?

I would be grateful for any reply or suggestion.

Reply | Report as offensive | Link